|
Restaurants -
Best of Taste
|
|
Written by Alexandra Pecci
|
|
|

The Seacoast region has hundreds of dining options, and we all have our preferences. We asked you to get out and vote for your favorite restaurants, bars, sandwiches, and other eateries and dishes here and beyond, and you certainly came through! We tallied thousands of votes to determine the best in more than 70 categories, from Bagels to Wings, with ethnic cuisine, lobster rolls, markets, and much more in between.
Many thanks to the chefs, restaurateurs, brewers, bakers, sommeliers, farmers, and
other food professionals who have established wonderful culinary destinations and created amazing tastes. It’s your hard work that makes the Seacoast such an exciting place to dine.
And now–the Best of Taste 2011!
|
The Bagel Works Cafe
|
Bagel Shop: The Works Bakery Café
At The Works Bakery Café, the bagels are made with unbleached, unbromated flour and boiled and baked onsite at each of its six locations in New Hampshire, Maine, and Vermont. Although “the works” bagel is the most popular of the more than two dozen available, seasonal varieties like spinach onion keep the selections changing year-round.
9 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-4434, worksbakerycafe.com
Runners-up:
Panera Bread, multiple locations, panerabread.com
The Bagelry, Durham, N.H., bagelrynh.com
Bagel Caboose, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-5099
|
Ceres Bakery
|
Bakery: Ceres Bakery
Homemade goodies and family recipes are the hallmark of Ceres. But this is one bakery that goes beyond cupcakes and cookies, with seasonal specialties like mint brownies in the summer and stöllen, made with currents and candied orange peel, in the fall. The crumbly-chewy Snitz cookies, with lemon zest, pecans, dark chocolate, and oats, are another favorite. 51 Penhallow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-6518, ceresbakery.com
Runners-up:
Beach Pea Baking Co., Kittery, Maine, beachpeabaking.com
Popovers on the Square, Portsmouth, N.H., popoversonthesquare.com
Congdon’s Doughnuts, Wells, Maine, congdons.com
|
Bar: Poco’s Bow Street Cantina
With indoor and outdoor bars, Poco’s is a favorite in winter for folks who crave the cozy comfort of a sofa in front of the fireplace and in summer for those who enjoy fresh air with their sips. Either way, regulars appreciate a bartender who knows their favorite drink. Co-owner Marlisa Geroulo credits the bar staff for keeping the drink menu fresh and innovative.
37 Bow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5967, pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Runners-up:
The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthbrewery.com
Rí Rá, Portsmouth, N.H., rira.com
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
|
The Portsmouth Brewery
|
Bar Food: The Portsmouth Brewery
At New Hampshire’s favorite brewery, beer is an ingredient, not just a beverage. There’s beer-battered haddock and calamari, Blonde Ale–poached chicken, and barbecue sauce made with Old Brown Dog Ale. In addition to the regular menu, a bar menu served until midnight on the weekends includes fun snacks like spicy nut brittle and a meatball martini. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, portsmouthbrewery.com
Runners-up:
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
The Coat of Arms, Portsmouth, N.H., coatofarmspub.com
The Rusty Hammer, Portsmouth, N.H., therustyhammer.com
|
Jay Geigley, Poco's Bow Street Cantina
|
Bartender: Jay Geigley, Poco’s Bow Street Cantina
Jay Geigley has been pouring drinks and making customers laugh behind Poco’s bar for nine summers now, and he credits the fun he has doing his job with his win in this category. “I love interacting with people,” he says. “I like making sure people have a good time.” Many of his drink creations wind up on Poco’s menu, including the refreshing Citrus Sparkler, made with Prosecco, Finlandia Grapefruit Fusion, and grapefruit juice. 7 Bow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5967, pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Runners-up:
Sam Costanzo, Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., radicirestaurant.com
Donna Marcotte, The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthbrewery.com
Kelly Whitney, Billy’s Chowder House, Wells, Maine, billyschowderhouse.com
|
BBQ: Mojo’s BBQ Grill and Tavern
The 14-hour-slow-smoked pulled pork, BBQ beans, dry-rubbed ribs, and other specialties at MoJo’s all add up to seriously excellent BBQ. The restaurant also sells its signature sauces by the bottle, including super-hot varieties made from habanero and jolokia peppers that aren’t intended, the menu warns, “for consumption by children and sissies.” 95 Brewery Lane, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-6656, mojosbbqshack.com
Runners-up:
Goody Cole’s Smokehouse, Brentwood, N.H., goodycoles.com
Roundabout Diner, Portsmouth, N.H., roundaboutdiner.com
Mainely BBQ, Kittery, Maine, 207-703-0361
|
Bed & Breakfast: The Sise Inn
With 34 guest rooms and suites and three meeting rooms, the Sise Inn combines the amenities of a small hotel with the personalized feel of a B&B. The breakfast room is open around the clock, and a comfortable parlor invites guests to relax with a glass of wine. Formerly home to Portsmouth merchant John E. Sise, the inn is “historic, just like the city,” says owner and innkeeper Diane Hodun. 40 Court Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-1200, siseinn.com
Runners-up:
Three Chimneys Inn, Durham, N.H., threechimneysinn.com
The York Harbor Inn, York Harbor, Maine, yorkharborinn.com
Martin Hill Inn, Portsmouth, N.H., martinhillinn.com
|
Beer Selection: The Portsmouth Brewery
More than 250,000 pints are served every year at the Portsmouth Brewery, and each one is made by hand. Traditional ales and lagers are on tap, of course, but there are lots of seasonal and unusual beers, too, such as Blueberry, Pumpkin Ale, and Wild Thang, which gets its nutty and cherry flavors from wild rice and sterling hops. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, portsmouthbrewery.com
Runners-up:
The Coat of Arms, Portsmouth, N.H., coatofarmspub.com
Rí Rá, Portsmouth, N.H., rira.com
Redhook Ale Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., redhook.com
|
The Golden Egg
|
Breakfast: The Golden Egg
Fresh food is the order of the day at The Golden Egg, which has been a favorite with locals since it opened in 1983. Homemade baked goods and fantastic specials are staples, and the restaurant has just added a line of gluten-free muffins and desserts. 960 Sagamore Avenue, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-0519, goldeneggrestaurant.com
Runners-up:
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., thefriendlytoast.net
Colby’s Breakfast & Lunch Joint, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3033
Congdon’s Doughnuts, Wells, Maine, congdons.com
|
Brew Pub: The Portsmouth Brewery
With a lounge, bar, restaurant, and patio, plus a huge beer and food selection, the Portsmouth Brewery continues its reign as the Seacoast’s favorite brew pub. The brewery also offers tours and special discount events, such as Dollar Tacos nights in the lounge. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, portsmouthbrewery.com
Runners-up:
Redhook Ale Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., redhook.com
Federal Jack’s Brew Pub, Kennebunk, Maine, federaljacks.com
Shipyard Brew Pub, Eliot, Maine, shipyardbrewpub.com
|
Brunch: Wentworth by the Sea
Live jazz, an ocean view, and a grand dame of a hotel make Sunday brunch at the Wentworth the height of opulence. Hosted in the Wentworth Grand Dining Room, the brunch features custom-order cooking stations and a decadent menu, including mimosas, oysters on the half shell, prime rib, and an abundances of sweets, like petits fours and crème brulee. 588 Wentworth Road, New Castle, N.H., 603-373-6566, wentworth.com
Runners-up:
Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., radicirestaurant.com
Pepperland Café, South Berwick, Maine, pepperlandcafe.com
The Old Salt, Hampton, N.H., oldsaltnh.com
|
Burger: Wild Willy’s Burger
Certified Angus beef, no frozen meat, and homemade burger patties add up to the Seacoast’s favorite burger. Plus, they’re cooked on a char-broiler, not a flat grill, so “you get that nice backyard smoky flavor,” says Bruce Rascher, assistant manager at the York location. And fries made from Maine potatoes make a great burger even better. 765 US Route 1, York, Maine, 207-363-9924, wildwillysburgers.com
Runners-up:
Lexie’s Joint, Portsmouth, N.H., lexiesjoint.com
The Rusty Hammer, Portsmouth, N.H., therustyhammer.com
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
|
Burrito: Loco Coco’s Tacos
Fresh ingredients are just one of the reasons to love the burritos at Loco Coco’s, which serves San Diego–style Mexican food from co-owners Ramona Robinson and Tijuana native Luis Valdez. Favorites include the Carne Asada Burrito, grilled marinated steak plus rice, beans, salsa, lettuce, guacamole, and sour cream. 36 Walker Street, Kittery, Maine, 207-438-9322, locococos.com
Runners-up:
Dos Amigos Burritos, Concord, Dover, and Portsmouth, N.H., dosamigosburritos.com
Las Olas Taqueria, Exeter and Hampton, N.H., lasolastaqueria.com
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant, several locations, margs.com
|
Business Lunch: Rudi’s Portsmouth
Whether it’s hosting a quiet lunch for two or accommodating a
party of 20 on an hour’s notice, Rudi’s prides itself on providing exceptional service for business folks from Portland to Boston. “We know our customers by name, and we know what they like before they sit down,” says day manager Nicole Menard. 20 High Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-430-7834, rudisportsmouth.com
Runners-up:
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthbrewery.com
The Library Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., libraryrestaurant.com
|
Butcher Shop: The Meat House
The Meat House is known for its extensive selection of meats, including dry-aged beef and all-natural cuts, as well as its customer service. The shop also has more than 250 wine labels. The Portsmouth location is one of several throughout the Seacoast.
2222 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-422-6328, themeathouse.com
Runners-up:
Carl’s Meat Market, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-1557
Joe’s Meat Shoppe, North Hampton, N.H., joesmeatshoppe.com
Shields Meat & Produce, Kennebunk, Maine, 207-985-3141
|
Caterer: The White Apron
Jay Curcio, chef owner of The White Apron, says, “Our motto in the kitchen is just ‘make good food.’” Curcio and Executive Chef Ben Reed always strive for perfection for everything from small corporate lunches to big-budget weddings. One Washington Place, Suite 1024, Dover, N.H., 603-617-3555, thewhiteapron.com
Runners-up:
Flavor Concepts, Dover, N.H., flavor-concepts.com
Galley Hatch, Hampton, N.H., galleyhatchcatering.com
Kitchen Chicks Catering, Kennebunk, Maine, kitchenchickscatering.com
|
Cheese Shop: Corks and Curds
According to owners Eldon and Cara Collymore, all the products at their wine and cheese shop are hand selected, including hard-to-find artisanal and raw milk cheeses and small-production wines. The shop also offers regular wine tastings and expert pairing advice. 13 Commercial Alley, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5564
Runners-up:
C’est Cheese, North Hampton, N.H., c-estcheese.com
South Street & Vine, Portsmouth, N.H., southstreetandvine.com
Cornucopia Wine and Cheese Market, Exeter, N.H., cwinecheese.com
|
Evan Mallett, Black Trumpet
|
Chef: Evan Mallett, Black Trumpet
Even Mallett had just spent the afternoon candying stems of a lovage plant when he learned that he’d won in this category for the second year running. And that pretty much sums up Mallett and his restaurant: working with wild, seasonal, and foraged ingredients; always learning, always pushing boundaries. “I feel honored,” says Mallett. “When it comes from readers it means so much more. Our clientele is people that we serve, and that’s just a really nice way of saying thank you.” He also shares the glory with his staff: “They hold me up every day. I get a lot of credit for what I do but they deserve a lot more for what they do.” 29 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-0887, blacktrumpetbistro.com
Runners-up:
Phelps Dieck, The Green Monkey, Portsmouth, N.H., thegreenmonkey.net
Joshua Mather, Joshua’s, Wells, Maine, joshuas.biz
Jeremy Bradbury, Mombo, Portsmouth, N.H., momborestaurant.com
|
Chili: Dos Amigos Burritos
Dos Amigos’ trademark (and secret) Amigo spice is just one of the reasons their chili is tops. It’s packed with pork tenderloin, steak, ground beef, and sausage, as well as beans and veggies. If that’s too much meat for you, Dos Amigos’ vegan chili is just as hearty, with 16 different kinds of beans along with celery, carrots, tomatoes, and corn. 107 State Street Portsmouth, N.H., 603-373-6001, dosamigosburritos.com
Runners-up:
The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthbrewery.com
Loco Coco’s Tacos, Kittery, Maine, locococos.com
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
|
Bryne & Carlson
|
Chocolatier: Byrne & Carlson
Byrne & Carlson brings international touches to its artisanal chocolates, using traditional old-world techniques, cocoa beans from Madagascar and West Africa and other exotic locales, glacé fruits from Australia, and hazelnut paste from Italy. It all combines to produce chocolates that mix the classical with the cutting-edge, from French truffles to chipotle sea-salt chocolate bars. 121 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., and 60 State Road, Kittery, Maine, 888-559-9778, byrneandcarlson.com
Runners-up:
Lindt, several locations, lindtusa.com
The Chocolatier, Exeter, N.H., the-chocolatier.com
Van Otis, Manchester, N.H., vanotischocolates.com
|
Clam Chowder:
Billy’s Chowder House
Shucking steamers and making chowder are a daily routine at Billy’s Chowder House. In addition to chopped clams, the chowder at Billy’s includes whole Maine steamers. And the thinner-than-usual base highlights the taste of the clams. “Thickness blands away the true flavor of the clam,” says general manager Chris Varano. 216 Mile Road, Wells, Maine, 207-646-7558, billyschowderhouse.com
Runners-up:
River House, Portsmouth, N.H., riverhouse53bow.com
Petey’s Restaurant, Rye, N.H., peteys.com
The Old Salt, Hampton, N.H., oldsaltnh.com
|
Coffee House: Breaking New Grounds
Dealing directly with farmers and roasting the beans onsite allow owner Matt Govoni to ensure that he’s serving the best and freshest coffee possible. This year, a favorite has been the “smooth, approachable” Ethiopian Yirgacheffe. A local dairy provides the shop’s milk and cream. 14 Market Square, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-9555
Runners-up:
Popovers on the Square, Portsmouth, N.H., popoversonthesquare.com
Adelle’s Coffeehouse, Dover, N.H., adellescoffeehouse.com
Caffe Kilim, Portsmouth, N.H., caffekilim.com
|
Comfort Food: The Common Man
Homey entrees like New England Pot Pie, Country Meatloaf, and Lobster Mac-and-Cheese combine with cozy fireplaces and squashy chairs to really put the “comfort” in comfort food. The Common Man specializes in traditional food with a flair. 96 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-334-6225, thecman.com
Runners-up:
Roundabout Diner, Portsmouth, N.H., roundaboutdiner.com
The Maine Diner, Wells, Maine, mainediner.com
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., thefriendlytoast.net
|
Cooking School: Stonewall Kitchen
Want to learn how to cook with coffee or prepare an Asian barbecue? Top chefs from around the region teach at Stonewall Kitchen’s flagship retail store in York, Maine. There are lunchtime classes, easygoing Sunday brunch classes, and evening sessions for casual and experienced cooks alike. 2 Stonewall Lane, York, Maine, 877-899-8363, stonewallkitchen.com
Runners-up:
Chez Boucher, Hampton, N.H., chezboucher.com
Attrezzi, Portsmouth, N.H., attrezzinh.com
Flavor Concepts, Dover, N.H., flavor-concepts.com
|
Robert's Maine Grill
|
Crab Cakes: Robert’s Maine Grill
Maine crabmeat and minimal filler are the magic ingredients in these light and fluffy pan-seared crab cakes. “The mouth feel is what people are most wowed by,” says owner Michael Landgarten. They’re served with a popular chipotle lime sauce. Route 1, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-0300, robertsmainegrill.com
Runners-up:
Jumpin’ Jay’s Fish Café, Portsmouth, N.H., jumpinjays.com
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
Mike’s Clam Shack, Wells, Maine, mikesclamshack.com
|
Deck: Poco’s Bow Street Cantina
It’s not just the flatscreen TV, sound system, and full bar that make the deck at Poco’s special. The structure itself is made from green building materials, says co-owner Marlisa Geroulo, who helped design the deck. Everything from the wood to the bar top to the heating and cooling system is environmentally friendly. 37 Bow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5967, pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Runners-up:
River House, Portsmouth, N.H., riverhouse53bow.com
Harpoon Willy’s, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-4441
The Old Ferry Landing, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthnh.com/dining/ferrylanding1.html
|
Deli: Googie’s Sandwich Shoppe
The huge selection at Googie’s ranges from wraps to customized sandwiches to a catering menu featuring a six-foot party sub. The shop also offers homemade ice cream, groceries, and hearty specials like beef and barley vegetable soup and curry chicken salad. 148 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-2052, eatatgoogies.com
Runners-up:
Joe’s Meat Shoppe, North Hampton, N.H., joesmeatshoppe.com
Billingsgate Deli/Market, Exeter, N.H., billingsgateeventcatering.com
Anthony’s Food Shop, York, Maine, anthonysfoodshop.com
|
Roundabout Diner
|
Diner: Roundabout Diner
Having an in-house pastry chef isn’t typical for a diner, but touches like that should come as no surprise when Dan Posternak, the original owner of Muddy River Smokehouse, is at the helm. The result is a nostalgic 1950s diner with a twist, with dishes like a Reuben sandwich with slow-cooked corned beef and an award-winning Banana Cream Pie. 580 US Highway 1 Bypass (Portsmouth Traffic Circle), Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1440, roundaboutdiner.com
Runners-up:
The Maine Diner, Wells, Maine, mainediner.com
Gilley’s PM Lunch, Portsmouth, N.H., gilleyspmlunch.com
The Red Arrow, Manchester, N.H., redarrowdiner.com
|
Farm Stand: Portsmouth Farmers’ Market
This weekly farmers’ market features more than two dozen Seacoast vendors, from Applecrest Farm Orchards to Zach’s Farm, selling everything from seasonal produce, prepared foods, meat, cheese, eggs, and wine, to fresh-cut flowers, crafts, and body care products. Saturdays, 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. (May–early November) City Hall Lot,
1 Junkins Avenue, Portsmouth, N.H., seacoastgrowers.org/portsmouth-farmers-market
Runners-up:
Chase Farm, Wells, Maine, chasefarmswells.com
Baker’s Farmstand, Stratham, N.H., 603-778-1039
Golden Harvest Produce Market, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-2113 |
Fine Dining: Black Trumpet
“I’m especially honored to win an award like this in this town right now,” says Executive Chef Evan Mallett, who co-owns the restaurant with his wife, Denise. He emphasizes that he couldn’t run Black Trumpet alone, and calls his experienced staff “the best, bar none.” The atmosphere at Black Trumpet is elegant yet comfortable, with a menu that reflects true attention to ingredient details, be it a Spring Lamb Sirloin Steak with Braised Lamb Shank, Dayboat Scallops, or fine desserts like Maine Sea Salt Chocolate Creme Brulee. 29 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-0887, blacktrumpetbistro.com
Runners-up:
Ristorante Massimo, Portsmouth, N.H., ristorantemassimo.com
The Library Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., libraryrestaurant.com
Mombo, Portsmouth, N.H., momborestaurant.com |
Fried Seafood: Petey’s Summertime Seafood and Bar
Not only is all the seafood fresh and local, but some of the lobsters served at Petey’s come right off owner Peter Aikens’ own lobster boat. Heaping plates of fried seafood served with french fries are a hallmark here, including the very popular Fried Lobster Tails. 1323 Ocean Boulevard, Rye, N.H., 603-433-1937, peteys.com
Runners-up:
Bob’s Clam Hut, Kittery, Maine, bobsclamhut.com
Mike’s Clam Shack, Wells, Maine, mikesclamshack.com
Weathervane, multiple locations, weathervaneseafoods.com
|
Gourmet Food Market: Philbrick’s Fresh Market
Known for its organic produce, meats, and wine, Philbrick’s Fresh Market also focuses on carrying products that are fresh, local, and sustainable. Prepared foods are made on site. 775 Lafayette Road (Route 1), Portsmouth, N.H., 603-422-6758, and 69 Lafayette Road (Route 1), North Hampton, N.H., 603-379-2500, philbricksfreshmarket.com
Runners-up:
Fiddlehead Farms Marketplace, Dover, N.H., fiddleheadfarmsmarket.com
Stonewall Kitchen, York, Maine, stonewallkitchen.com
On the Vine Marketplace, Exeter, N.H., onthevinemarketplace.com
|
Health Food Market: Portsmouth Health Food Center
Owner Scott Nelson’s organic farm provides much of the fresh produce for his 35-year-old market; his farm’s bounty even winds up in the store’s prepared food. There’s a wide selection of all kinds of natural foods, including many from local purveyors. 151 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-1722, portsmouthhealthfood.com
Runners-up:
Philbrick’s Fresh Market, Portsmouth and North Hampton, N.H., philbricksfreshmarket.com
Dover Natural Marketplace & Café, Dover, N.H., 603-749-9999
Rising Tide Natural Foods, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-8898
|
Ice Cream: Annabelle’s Natural Ice Cream
Annabelle’s 16-plus-percent butterfat ice cream is considered super premium—to your taste buds, that translates to super creamy and super dense. The ice cream is kosher and all natural, which means there are no artificial colors or ingredients in great flavors like summery
Peach, New Hampshire Pure Maple Walnut, and Black Raspberry. 49 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3400, annabellesicecream.com
Runners-up:
Lago’s Lone Oak, Rye, N.H., lagos-lone-oak.com
Big Daddy’s, Wells, Maine, 207-646-5454
Brown’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream, York, Maine, 207-363-1277 |
Kid Friendly: Flatbread Company
There’s a lot for kids to love about Flatbread Company, with its huge wood-burning earthen ovens, colorful decor, and easy-going atmosphere. And since Flatbread uses organic ingredients and nitrate-free meats, parents can feel good about having pizza for dinner. 138 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-7888, flatbreadcompany.com
Runners-up:
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., thefriendlytoast.net
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., margs.com
Mike’s Clam Shack, Wells, Maine, mikesclamshack.com
|
Kitchen Store: Stonewall Kitchen
Stonewall Kitchen products are found at stores throughout the country, but there’s something special about coming to the flagship store. Shelves are loaded with kitchen gadgets and specialty foods. 2 Stonewall Lane, York, Maine, 207-351-2712, stonewallkitchen.com
Runners-up:
LeRoux Kitchen, Portsmouth, N.H., lerouxkitchen.com
Attrezzi, Portsmouth, N.H., attrezzinh.com
Keys to the Kitchen, Kennebunkport, Maine, keystothekitchen.com
|
Late Night: Gilley’s PM Lunch
The late-night fare at Gilley’s got even better when an expanded grill space allowed the Portsmouth nightspot to serve grilled sandwiches all night long. But don’t worry; there’s still plenty of room for an after-hours hamburger if the craving strikes. 175 Fleet Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-6343, gilleyspmlunch.com
Runners-up:
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., thefriendlytoast.net
The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthbrewery.com
Ceia’s Kitchen + Bar, Newburyport, MA, www.ceia-newburyport.com
|
Warren's Lobster House
|
Lobster Dinner: Warren’s Lobster House
With a win in this category under his belt for three years running, owner Scott Cunningham chalks up Warren’s success to great cooks and great service. Fresh lobster can’t hurt either, though. They source their lobsters as locally as possible, including from the Chrissy D. Lobster Company, a lobster pound that’s attached to the restaurant. An extensive salad bar with some 60 items complements the lobster dinner. 11 Water Street, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-1630, lobsterhouse.com
Runners-up:
Chauncey Creek Lobster Pier, Kittery Point, Maine, chaunceycreek.com
Petey’s Summertime Seafood and Bar, Rye, N.H., peteys.com
Newick’s, Dover and Concord, N.H., South Portland, Maine, newicks.com
|
The Beach Plum
|
Lobster Roll: The Beach Plum
The Beach Plum’s lobster roll isn’t just a hot dog bun with a little lobster meat thrown in. Instead, the restaurant, which has locations in Portsmouth and North Hampton, offers both a traditional lobster roll and a foot-long version, stuffed with lobster chunks and served with chips. 17 Ocean Boulevard (Route 1A), North Hampton, N.H., 603-964-7451, and 2800 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-3339, thebeachplum.net
Runners-up:
Billy’s Chowder House, Wells, Maine, billyschowderhouse.com
Hebert Brothers Seafood, West Kittery, Maine, hebertbrothers.com
Bob’s Clam Hut, Kittery, Maine, bobsclamhut.com
|
Locally Sourced: Black Trumpet
“Menus don’t get more seasonal than ours,” says chef and co-owner Evan Mallett. And local ingredients that follow what’s in season are the reason for that. Mallett says the menu changes completely about every six weeks and includes a wide variety of wild, foraged, and local ingredients. 29 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-0887, blacktrumpetbistro.com
Runners-up:
Street, Portsmouth, N.H., streetfood360.com
Flatbread Company, Portsmouth, N.H., flatbreadcompany.com
Blue Moon Evolution, Exeter, N.H., bluemoonevolution.com
|
Margarita: Margaritas Mexican Restaurant
How much of a shock can it be when a restaurant named Margaritas has the best ’ritas around? Still, tasting is believing; the restaurant uses its own mix made from freshly squeezed lemon and lime juices. There are also fun varieties like pomegranate and sour apple. 775 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5828, margs.com
Runners-up:
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Agave Mexican Bistro, Portsmouth, N.H., agavedos.com
Loco Coco’s Tacos, Kittery, Maine, 207-438-9322, locococos.com
|
Martini: The Green Monkey Martini
The Green Monkey has a new cocktail list, but its namesake martini is still available. It features pineapple vodka, Midori, and a splash of pineapple and lemon juices. Makes it very easy to be green. 86 Pleasant Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-427-1010, thegreenmonkey.net
Runners-up:
The Red Door, Portsmouth, N.H., reddoorportsmouth.com
Two Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., twoceresstreet.com
Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., radicirestaurant.com
|
New Restaurant: Mombo
Many restaurants have seasonal menus, but Mombo takes the concept one step further. “We’ve adopted a living menu, which means that it changes almost like the weather,” says Thomas Perron, general manager and executive chef. “Something for everyone” really applies here: Mombo can accommodate diners looking for intimate fireside romance or those who want to have a good time at the piano bar. 66 Marcy Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-2340, momborestaurant.com
Runners-up:
106 Kitchen and Bar, Portsmouth, N.H., 106kitchen.com
The Chef’s Table, Portsmouth, N.H., chefstableatportsmouth.com
Lexie’s Joint, Portsmouth, N.H., lexiesjoint.com |
Nightlife Bar: Poco’s Bow Street Cantina
With an indoor bar and dining room, two-story deck with outdoor bar, plus a lounge area, Poco’s is tops for having a drink with friends, unwinding after work, or letting loose on the weekend. 7 Bow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5967, pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Runners-up:
Rí Rá, Portsmouth, N.H., rira.com
The Red Door, Portsmouth, N.H., reddoorportsmouth.com
Portsmouth Gaslight Co., Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthgaslight.com
|
Pizza: Flatbread Company
Maybe it’s the traditional, wood-burning ovens; maybe it’s the emphasis on local, organic ingredients; maybe it’s toppings like homemade pepperoni and sausage. But any way you slice it, Flatbread’s pizza stands apart from the typical delivery fare. 138 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-7888, flatbreadcompany.com
Runners-up:
LaFesta Brick & Brew, Dover, N.H., lafestabrickandbrew.com
Portsmouth Gaslight Co., Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthgaslight.com
Savario’s Pizza & Calzones, Portsmouth, N.H., seacoastnh.com/savarios
|
Restaurant View: The Wellington Room
With its sweeping view of the Piscataqua River, The Wellington Room keeps racking up our “best view” award, winning in 2011 for the third year running. But one cannot live on a view alone, and The Wellington Room’s menu, with an emphasis on fresh, hand-selected ingredients, keeps diners coming back for more. 67 Bow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-2989, thewellingtonroom.com
Runners-up:
River House, Portsmouth, N.H., riverhouse53bow.com
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Latitudes at Wentworth by the Sea, New Castle, N.H., wentworth.com
|
Radici
|
Restaurant: Radici
From easy-going brunches to decadent desserts, everything at this year’s best restaurant winner sings la dolce vita. Downtown Portsmouth’s ode to the Italian Old Country encourages diners to slow down and drink life in, whether that means long, lingering conversations over tiramisu or sipping a glass of vino from the ever-evolving wine list. House specials include entrees like Osso Bucco, Primavera Orecchiette, and Haddock Gremolata. Radici’s brunch is also among the Seacoast’s best and goes beyond the typical pastries and quiche to include frittatas, antipasti, and sweet, delicate crespelle. Buon appetito! 142-144 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-373-6464, radicirestaurant.com
|
Ristorante Massimo
|
Romantic: Ristorante Massimo
Imagine cozying up to your sweetheart over authentic Italian food, sharing a plate of prosciutto-wrapped figs and sipping a glass of Cabernet Sauvignon. The “romance special” is not actually on the menu at Ristorante Massimo—it comes with every dish. 59 Penhallow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-4000, ristorantemassimo.com
Runners-up:
The Wellington Room, Portsmouth, N.H., thewellingtonroom.com
Mombo, Portsmouth, N.H., momborestaurant.com
Joshua’s, Wells, Maine, joshuas.biz
|
Sandwich: Moe’s Italian Sandwiches
Moe’s sandwiches are available in three sizes, ranging from 6 inches to a super-stuffed 12-incher with extra everything, from meat to cheese to pickles. Moe’s Original Italian sandwich has been a classic for decades, and it’s still made the same way, with mild salami, provolone cheese, and lots of everything. 22 Daniel Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-2327, moesitaliansandwiches.com
Runners-up:
Ceres Bakery, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-6518, ceresbakery.com
The Beach Pea Baking Co., Kittery, Maine, beachpeabaking.com
The Green Bean, Exeter, Portsmouth, Dover, N.H., nhgreenbean.com
|
Seaport Fish
|
Seafood Market: Seaport Fish
Every piece of seafood that comes into Seaport Fish comes in whole and is processed onsite, and they distribute everything themselves, too. Owner Rich Pettigrew, whose family has owned the business since 1978, says there’s an additional focus on buying as much local fish as possible. Seaport Fish also sells prepared items such as bisques and chowders. 13 Sagamore Road, Rye, N.H., 603-436-7286, seaportfish.com
Runners-up:
Sanders Fish Market, Portsmouth, N.H., sandersfish.com
Mike’s Fish Market and Lobster Pound, Wells, Maine, mikesclamshack.com
Hebert Brothers Seafood, West Kittery, Maine, hebertbrothers.com
|
Jumpin' Jay's Fish Cafe
|
Seafood Restaurant: Jumpin’ Jay’s Fish Café
Jumpin’ Jay’s emphasizes food that’s fresh and clean, from the entrees to the raw bar. “We celebrate the flavors of the ocean,” says general manager Kate McGrath. “We don’t mask the flavors of the fish.” The house specialty is the Haddock Piccata; other favorites include Yellow Fin Tuna Niçoise and San Francisco Cioppino. 150 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-766-3474, jumpinjays.com
Runners-up:
Petey’s Summertime Seafood and Bar, Rye, N.H., peteys.com
Billy’s Chowder House, Wells, Maine, billyschowderhouse.com
Warren’s Lobster House, Kittery, Maine, lobsterhouse.com
|
Special Occasion: Black Trumpet
With wins in the fine dining and best chef categories this year, it’s no wonder that when people on the Seacoast want to celebrate a special occasion, they head to Black Trumpet. The great food is obvious, but the space itself is beautiful and historic, too, and people love what they see when they walk in. “They gasp,” says chef and co-owner Evan Mallett. “It’s just the coolest space.” 29 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-0887, blacktrumpetbistro.com
Runners-up:
Mombo, Portsmouth, N.H., momborestaurant.com
Ristorante Massimo, Portsmouth, N.H., ristorantemassimo.com
Wentworth by the Sea, New Castle, N.H., wentworth.com
|
Sports Bar: The Page Restaurant and Bar
Bigger is better at The Page, which has a huge space, tons of TV screens, and more than just a sports bar, featuring; a bar menu, a burger menu, a regular menu, and a drink menu. And with bands, a nightclub, game-night competitions, and big prizes, owner Ted Mountzuris says The Page is more like an entertainment facility. 172 Hanover Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-0004, pageportsmouth.com
Runners-up:
TJ’s Food and Spirits, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-0844
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
Mojo’s BBQ Grill & Tavern, Portsmouth, N.H., mojosbbqshack.com
|
Steakhouse: The Library Restaurant
Housed in a brick mansion that was once the home of Judge Woodbury Langdon, this circa 1785 building is the ideal setting
for a stately steakhouse. Yet the atmosphere is unpretentious and the food outstanding, with several USDA prime cuts available, all aged at least four weeks, including the 16-ounce Gentleman’s Cut. 401 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5202, libraryrestaurant.com
Runners-up:
Four Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., fouronstate.com
Wells Beach Steakhouse, Wells, Maine, wellsbeachsteakhouse.com
Orchard Street Chop Shop, Dover, N.H., orchardstreetchopshop.com
|
Sushi: Shio Japanese Restaurant & Sushi Bar
The variety of sushi at Shio is fantastic. For a truly authentic Japanese experience, head to one of the restaurant’s Tatami rooms, with traditional seating mats on the floor and bamboo accents. 2454 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-319-1638, shiojpnh.com
Runners-up:
Sake Japanese Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthsake.com
East Restaurant & Lounge, Wells, Maine, eastdining.com
Oriental Delight Chinese & Japanese Cuisine & Cocktails, Dover, N.H., orientaldelightdover.com
|
Blue Moon Evolution
|
Vegetarian: Blue Moon Evolution
“We have been focused on light vegetarian fare for 16 years,” says owner Kath Gallant. “Health and wellness have been part of our focus.” The menus change all the time, but there are perennial favorites, like the Evolution Best Ever Wrap, made with a raw sunflower seed pate, veggies, and mock Caesar cashew dressing on a sprouted wrap.
8 Clifford Street, Exeter, N.H., 603-778-6850, bluemoonevolution.com
Runners-up:
Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., radicirestaurant.com
Flatbread Company, Portsmouth, N.H., flatbreadcompany.com
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., thefriendlytoast.net
|
Cava Tapas and Wine Bar
|
Wine List: Cava Tapas and Wine Bar
Every bottle of wine at Cava Tapas and Wine Bar, from the least expensive up to those with a $400 price tag, is offered by the half and full glass, says co-owner John Akar. That’s one thing that sets this wine bar apart, but it’s not the only one: Cava also brings in four to six new wines every week and carries many that can’t be found in New Hampshire state liquor stores. 10 Commercial Alley, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-319-1575, cavatapasandwinebar.com
Runners-up:
Black Trumpet, Portsmouth, N.H., blacktrumpetbistro.com
Ristorante Massimo, Portsmouth, N.H., ristorantemassimo.com
Ceia Kitchen + Bar, Newburyport, Mass., ceia-newburyport.com
|
Wine Shop: Dover Wine Company
“We provide wines at a good price,” says manager James Blaubelt, who notes that an average cost of $20 per bottle makes wine fun and accessible. Plus, the friendly staff encourages people to broaden their palates and try new things. The store has gained a devoted local following through its classes and tastings. 364 Central Avenue, Dover, N.H., 603-742-9463, doverwine.com
Runners-up:
Corks and Curds, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5564
Ceres Street Wine Merchant, Portsmouth, N.H., cereswine.com
South Street & Vine, Portsmouth, N.H., southstreetandvine.com
|
Wings: Wings Your Way
“We serve the biggest wing around,” says co-owner Cory Nadilo, adding that their wings have “double the meat” compared with other wing joints. They also have more than 20 sauces and rubs. Top sellers are good-old-fashioned classic Buffalo Wings, as well as Cajun and Honey BBQ. But with a menu full of wraps, burgers, and other goodies, Nadilo says, “we’re way more than wings.” 1181 Elm Street, Manchester, N.H., 603-836-5150, wingsyourway.com
Runners-up:
Wing-Itz, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-9464
Bratskellar, Portsmouth, N.H., dinnerhorn.com
MoJo’s BBQ Grill and Tavern, Portsmouth, N.H., mojosbbqshack.com
|
Flag Hill Winery
|
Winery: Flag Hill Winery
Boasting the largest vineyard in the state, Flag Hill makes all its wines from grapes grown right in New Hampshire. According to Frank Reinhold, president of Flag Hill, the winery is housed in a converted family farm that was first built in 1796, allowing visitors to both sample one of 17 different wines and also get a little bit of history. 297 North River Road (Route 155), Lee, N.H., 603-659-2949, flaghill.com
Runners-up:
Jewell Towne Vineyards, South Hampton, N.H., jewelltownevineyards.com
Zorvino Vineyards, Sandown, N.H., zorvino.com
Nashoba Valley Winery, Bolton, Mass., nashobawinery.com
|
Top 20 Restaurants
1. Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., radicirestaurant.com
2. Black Trumpet, Portsmouth, N.H., blacktrumpetbistro.com
3. Ristorante Massimo, Portsmouth, N.H., ristorantemassimo.com
4. Mombo, Portsmouth, N.H., momborestaurant.com
5. Cava, Portsmouth, N.H., cavatapasandwinebar.com
6. The Green Monkey, Portsmouth, N.H., thegreenmonkey.net
7. Café Mediterráneo, Portsmouth, N.H., cafe-mediterraneo.com
8. Robert’s Maine Grill, Kittery, Maine, robertsmainegrill.com
9. Brazo, Portsmouth, N.H., brazorestaurant.com
10. Library Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., libraryrestaurant.com
11. River House, Portsmouth, N.H., riverhouse53bow.com
12. Shio Japanese Restaurant & Sushi Bar, Portsmouth, N.H., shiojpnh.com
13. Anneke Jans, Kittery, Maine, annekejans.net
14. Agave Mexican Bistro, Portsmouth, N.H., agavedos.com
15. Ceia Kitchen + Bar, Newburyport, Mass., ceia-newburyport.com
16. The Common Man, Portsmouth, N.H., thecman.com
17. Jumpin’ Jay’s Fish Cafe, Portsmouth, N.H., jumpinjays.com
18. The Wellington Room, Portsmouth, N.H., thewellingtonroom.com
19. Bontá Restaurant and Bar, Hampton, N.H., bonta.net
20. Four, Portsmouth, N.H., fouronstate.com
|
|
Best Ethnic Cuisine
Chinese
Kim Lai
599 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H. 603-430-0761, kim-lai.com
RUNNERS-UP
East Restaurant & Lounge, Wells, Maine, eastdining.com
Ocean Wok, Hampton Beach, N.H., oceanwok.com
Green Leaves Chinese Restaurant, York, Maine, greenleavesrestaurant.com
Greek
Café Nostimo
72 Mirona Road, Portsmouth, N.H. 603-436-3100, cafenostimo.com
RUNNERS-UP
Athens, Manchester, N.H., 603-623-9317
Pauly’s Pockets, Durham, N.H., paulyspockets.com
Ithaki Mediterranean Cuisine, Ipswich, Mass., ithakicuisine.com
Indian
Shalimar India
80 Hanover Street, Portsmouth, N.H. 603-427-2959, shalimarindia.com
RUNNERS-UP
Tulsi, Kittery, Maine, tulsiindianrestaurant.com
Taste of India, Dover, N.H., taste-of-india.org
Mr. India Restaurant, Newburyport, Mass., misterindiarestaurant.com
IRISH PUB
Rí Rá
22 Market Square, Portsmouth, N.H. 603-319-1680, rira.com
RUNNERS-UP
Féile Restaurant & Pub, Wells, Maine, feilerestaurantandpub.com
Kelley’s Row Restaurant & Cellar Pub, Dover, N.H., kelleysrow.com
The Coat of Arms British Pub and Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., coatofarmspub.com
ITALIAN
Ristorante Massimo
59 Penhallow Street, Portsmouth, N.H. 603-436-4000, Portsmouth, N.H., ristorantemassimo.com
RUNNERS-UP
Café Mediterraneo, Portsmouth, N.H., cafe-mediterraneo.com
The Rosa, Portsmouth, N.H., therosa.com
Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., radicirestaurant.com
JAPANESE
Shio Japanese Restaurant
2454 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H. 603-319-1638, shiojpnh.com
RUNNERS-UP
Sake Japanese Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., portsmouthsake.com
Hibachi Japanese Steak House, Portsmouth, N.H., hibachinh.com
East Restaurant & Lounge, Wells, Maine, eastdining.com
MEXICAN
Loco Coco’s Tacos
36 Walker Street, Kittery, Maine, 207-438-9322, locococos.com
RUNNERS-UP
Agave Mexican Bistro, Portsmouth, N.H., agavedos.com
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., margs.com
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., pocosbowstreetcantina.com
THAI
Tasty Thai
182 State Road, Kittery, Maine 207-439-9988, tastythaikittery.com
RUNNERS-UP
Thai Paradise, Portsmouth, N.H., thaiparadisecusine.com
Pad Thai Restaurant, Exeter, N.H., padthaiexeter.com
Thai Cuisine, Dover, N.H., thaicuisine.com
|
|
Best Inexpensive Eats
A full day’s worth of good food and great value.
BREAKFAST
Café Espresso
Everything’s under 10 bucks on the breakfast menu here, and there’s a wide selection, from different varieties of French toast, pancakes, and waffles to café specials and creative omelets like the Sweet Pea, with bacon and hollandaise. There are also five benedict-style dishes, including the Holy Guacamole Bene, topped with guac and salsa. 738 Islington Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-334-3407, cafe--espresso.com
RUNNERS-UP
Colby’s Breakfast & Lunch Joint, Portsmouth, 603-436-3033 Congdon’s Doughnuts, Wells, Maine, congdons.com
The Golden Egg, Portsmouth, N.H., goldeneggrestaurant.com
LUNCH
Café Nostimo
The hearty portions and low prices not only make this Greek restaurant a great lunch value, but also help people get out of the “rut of the sandwich,” says Nancy Zottos, who co-owns Café Nostimo with her husband, Dean. The salads are made to order, the spanakopita is homemade, and the meat is cut and marinated on site. Madison Village, 72 Mirona Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3100, cafenostimo.com
RUNNERS-UP
The 401 Tavern, Hampton, N.H., the401tavern.com
Ceres Bakery, Portsmouth, N.H., ceresbakery.com
The Green Bean, several locations, nhgreenbean.com
DINNER
Café Nostimo
A large menu and great prices make this Greek restaurant a sure bet for awesome eats on the cheap. Homemade food, hearty portions, and traditional recipes mean that diners get a solid bang for their buck with specialty plates like slow-roasted baked lamb shank, served with Greek salad or green beans and rice pilaf or fries. Madison Village, 72 Mirona Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3100, cafenostimo.com
RUNNERS-UP
The Maine Diner, Wells, Maine, mainediner.com
Roundabout Diner, Portsmouth, N.H., roundaboutdiner.com
Gilley’s PM Lunch, Portsmouth, N.H., gilleyspmlunch.com
|
|
|
|
|
Winter/Spring 2012 on Newsstands Now! ------------
|
|

|
|