|
 We have an abundance of dining options in the Seacoast area, and everyone has a favorite. Taste asked you for yours—the votes are tallied and the results are in. We thank you for helping us name the best bars, restaurants, and other eateries. Local is the key word when it comes to our winners this year: locally sourced ingredients, purveyors, and flavors. Following are the best in each of dozens of categories, from Bakery to Wings, with all kinds of goodies in between.
Kudos to the chefs, restaurateurs, brewers, bakers, sommeliers, chocolatiers, and food professionals who have created such wonderful culinary destinations. It’s thanks to you that the Seacoast continues to be such an exciting place to eat.
Bakery
Beach Pea Baking Co.
Homemade food with nature-made ingredients—that’s Beach Pea’s menu and mission. Choose from mouthwatering cakes, tarts, and cookies, artisan and specialty breads, and fresh salads, soups, and handcrafted sandwiches. Beach Pea serves the local community, literally, by using local vendors for all-natural sweeteners, organic dried fruits and grains, nitrite-free meats, and dairy goods. Even the tofu in the Crispy Thai Tofu Sandwich hails from Maine. 53 State Road, Route 1, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-3555, www.beachpeabaking.com.
Runners-up:
Ceres Bakery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.ceresbakery.com
Popovers on the Square, Portsmouth, N.H., www.popoversonthesquare.com
Harvey’s Bakery and Coffee Shop, Dover, N.H., www.harveysbakery.com
Bar
The Portsmouth Brewery
The Portsmouth Brewery has been offering great food and its own fine, handcrafted beers since 1991. A lively, friendly atmosphere makes this pub a popular stop for lunch, dinner, or late-night fare. There’s even a kids’ menu. And check out the Brewer’s Table menu, featuring great food/beer pairings by Executive Chef Todd Sweet
and Head Brewer Tod Mott. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, www.portsmouthbrewery.com.
Runners-up:
Rí Rá, Portsmouth, N.H., www.rira.com
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., www.pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Coat of Arms British Pub and Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.coatofarmspub.com
Bar Food
The Portsmouth Brewery
Great handcrafted beer demands fresh-tasting food. Luckily, Executive Chef Todd Sweet, who joined the Portsmouth Brewery in the fall of 2009, makes it his mission to use local ingredients whenever possible. In the mood for a pint and a snack? Pop into the Jimmy LaPanza Lounge, where one featured item per night—chicken wings, empanadas, tacos, mussels, peel-and-eat shrimp—is a buck apiece or served in small portions for small money. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, www.portsmouthbrewery.com.
Runners-up:
The Rusty Hammer, Portsmouth, N.H., www.therustyhammer.com
Rí Rá, Portsmouth, N.H., www.rira.com
Coat of Arms British Pub and Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.coatofarmspub.com
 Bartender
Donna Marcotte, The Portsmouth Brewery
Donna has been with the Portsmouth Brewery since day one and has cultivated a legion of loyal bar customers on the weekday lunch shift, though she wears many other hats in the brewery as well. She recognizes you, recommends the right meals, and does all the little things that customers appreciate. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, www.portsmouthbrewery.com.
Runners-up:
Dave O’Shaunessy, Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., www.pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Chris Gansburg, Café Mediterráneo, Portsmouth, N.H., www.cafe-mediterraneo.com
Tom Hooper, Orchard Street Chop Shop, Dover, N.H., www.orchardstreetchopshop.com
BBQ
Mojo’s BBQ Grill & Tavern
Now that it’s moved to larger digs, Mojo’s is better than ever. Yes, the ribs are still fall-apart fabulous, and all the sauces and rubs are still made from scratch in the restaurant’s kitchen by Aaron “Jonesy” Jones. But now Mojo’s has a big dining room, full lounge area, live music nights, plenty of parking, and an expanded menu of apps, sandwiches, and burgers. 95 Brewery Lane, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-6656, www.mojosbbqshack.com.
Runners-up:
Muddy River Smokehouse, Portsmouth, N.H., www.muddyriver.com
Goody Cole’s Smokehouse, Brentwood, N.H., www.goodycoles.com
Eddie B’s, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-319-405 (no website)
Bed and Breakfast
The Sise Inn
This former home of John E. Sise, a prominent Portsmouth merchant in the late 1880s, is downtown and walkable to everything, making it ideal for vacationers, tourist groups, and business travelers. The beauty of its 19th-century architecture has been completely restored to grand style throughout the 34-room inn. Original woodwork, elegant antiques, and period reproductions recall the graciousness of Victorian life. 40 Court Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-1200 or toll free 877-747-3466, www.siseinn.com.
Runners-up:
Three Chimneys Inn, Durham, N.H., www.threechimneysinn.com
York Harbor Inn, York Harbor, Maine, www.yorkharborinn.com
Ale House Inn, Portsmouth, N.H., www.alehouseinn.com
Beer Selection
The Portsmouth Brewery
The Portsmouth Brewery serves over 250,000 pints each year, made by hand using traditional methods and ingredients. In addition to their year-round standards, traditional ales and lagers, and offbeat brews, there are a handful of new beers every year to try. Smuttynose, is on tap here, straight from the brewery’s sister company across town. For a place determined to stay small, local, and fresh, the Portsmouth Brewery offers an astounding variety. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, www.portsmouthbrewery.com.
Runners-up:
Rí Rá, Portsmouth, N.H., www.rira.com
Coat of Arms British Pub and Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.coatofarmspub.com
Redhook Ale Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.redhook.com
Breakfast
The Friendly Toast
With its funky, retro decor and fresher, fancier take on diner food (pumpkin pancakes, pecan-caramelized banana waffles, Vegan Valhalla burritos, Redneck roast beef sandwiches), The Friendly Toast could be one of the liveliest dining experiences around. Seacoast residents aren’t the only ones in the know: Melissa Jasper’s colorful, upbeat restaurant was one of four finalists in Good Morning America’s “Best Breakfast in America” contest. 121 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-430-2154, www.thefriendlytoast.net.
Runners-up:
The Golden Egg, Portsmouth, N.H., www.goldeneggrestaurant.com
Colby’s Breakfast & Lunch, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3033 (no website)
Café Espresso, Portsmouth, N.H., www.cafe--espresso.com
 Brewpub
The Portsmouth Brewery
Whether you want to relax in the downstairs lounge with its sofas and game tables, or prefer the upstairs with its lively bar, restaurant, and patio, you can enjoy all the same house-brewed beers and fresh-made meals. You can also find the same sense of community. Operating since 1991, New Hampshire’s oldest brewpub maintains tradition yet doesn’t stop evolving. 56 Market Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1115, www.portsmouthbrewery.com.
Runners-up:
Redhook Ale Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.redhook.com
Shipyard Brew Pub, Eliot, Maine, www.shipyardbrewpub.com
Gritty McDuff’s Brew Pub, Portland, Maine, www.grittys.com
Brunch
Wentworth by the Sea
This grand old hotel offers unmatched elegance for Sunday brunch, with sparkling fountains, shimmering ice sculptures, and crystal glasses and chandeliers. Chefs poised at a dozen stations in the grand dining room prepare a wide range of breakfast foods and entrees. The dessert table is laden with crème brûlée, chocolate-dipped strawberries, petit fours, and a host of other delectable treats. Spectacular views and live jazz enhance the experience. 588 Wentworth Road, New Castle, N.H., 603-373-6566, www.wentworth.com.
Runners-up:
The Old Salt, Hampton, N.H., www.oldsaltnh.com
Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., www.radicirestaurant.com
Pepperland Cafe, South Berwick, Maine, 207-384-5535 (no website)
Burger
The Rusty Hammer
This full-service restaurant is home of the “Wimpy,” a charbroiled 6-ounce burger offered 15 different ways. Choose from the classic burger to burgers covered with blue, Cheddar, or pepper jack cheese, bacon, sautéed mushrooms, or onions and garlic. Truly special creations include the Reuben Wimpy, a Caribbean-seasoned Island Wimpy, and the Cajun-inspired Louisiana Wimpy. Add great classic sides, and it’s hamburger heaven! 49 Pleasant Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-9289, www.therustyhammer.com.
Runners-up:
Wild Willy’s Burgers, South Portland and York, Maine, and Rochester, N.H., www.wildwillysburgers.com
Rocky’s Famous Burgers, Newmarket, N.H., www.rockysfamousburgers.com
Lexie’s Joint, Portsmouth, N.H., www.lexiesjoint.com
Burrito
Loco Coco’s Tacos
Co-owners Luis Valdez and Ramona Robinson have been serving freshly prepared, San Diego–style Mexican food to Kittery since 2004. A dining room expansion and new deck this summer prove customers can’t get enough! Freshly made flour tortillas hold a range of flavorful burrito fillings. The most popular is the Tia Margarita Fish Burrito made with crisp, beer-battered fish or shrimp—a generations-old recipe from Luis’s Mexican roots. 36 Walker Street, Kittery, Maine, 207-438-9322, www.locococos.com.
Runners-up:
Dos Amigos Burritos, Concord, Dover, and Portsmouth, N.H., www.dosamigosburritos.com
Las Olas Taqueria, Exeter and Hampton, N.H., www.lasolastaqueria.com
Agavé Mexican Bistro Dos, Portsmouth, N.H., www.agavemexicanbistrodos.com
 Business Lunch
Rudi’s Portsmouth
Whether you’re strategizing your next campaign, celebrating that promotion, or just needing an escape from the office, Rudi’s is the perfect choice. The atmosphere is comfortable and inviting, with refined touches that set the mood for good conversation (local art on the walls, the soft sounds of a grand piano in the background). The menu is distinctive yet not overly posh. Two private dining areas serve small or large functions. 20 High Street, Portsmouth, N.H. 603-430-7834, www.rudisportsmouth.com.
Runners-up:
The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.portsmouthbrewery.com
Popovers on the Square, Portsmouth, N.H., www.popoversonthesquare.com
Paddy’s American Grille, Portsmouth, N.H., www.paddysgrille.com
Café/Coffee
Breaking New Grounds
This coffee shop’s central location, outdoor seating, and free WiFi are just part of the appeal. Owner Matt Govoni hand-selects the coffee, dealing as directly as possible with individual coffee farms, and roasts the coffee right in the store. The freshness theme carries over to the delectable pastries and homemade gelato. 14 Market Square, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-9555 (no website).
Runners-up:
Popovers on the Square, Portsmouth, N.H.,
www.popoversonthesquare.com
Caffe Kilim, Portsmouth, N.H., www.caffekilim.com
Adelle’s Coffeehouse, Dover, N.H., www.adellescoffeehouse.com
 Caterer
The White Apron
Jay Curcio and Julie Reed Dunfey’s company doesn’t pump out giant quantities of food. But they make all of the food they serve themselves—from the hors d’oeuvres to the salad dressings to the desserts—and source their products from local vendors and producers whenever possible. Each client gets their personal attention, and they work hard to customize every event to match clients’ needs and exceed expectations. 28 Chapel Street, Dover, N.H., 603-617-3555, www.thewhiteapron.com.
Runners-up:
Galley Hatch Catering, Hampton, N.H., www.galleyhatch.com
Mizuna, Greenland, N.H., www.mizunanh.com
Blue Mermaid Island Grill, Portsmouth, N.H., www.bluemermaid.com
Cheese Shop
C’est Cheese
C’est Cheese has a diverse selection from every major cheese-producing region. Always ask for a sample of something new, and for culinary guidance if you need it—owner Nancy Guilmette was once a personal chef. She also carries a small, quality selection of domestic wines and gourmet imported specialty foods, such as sausages, olives, and pastas. And she loves making gift baskets and platters. 122 Lafayette Road, North Hampton, N.H., 603-964-2272, www.c-estcheese.com.
Runners-up:
Cornucopia Wine and Cheese, Exeter, N.H., www.cwinecheese.com
South Street & Vine, Portsmouth, N.H., www.southstreetandvine.com
Dover Wine Company, Dover, N.H., www.doverwine.com
 Chef
Evan Mallett, Black Trumpet
“I’m humbled and honored,” says chef-owner Evan Mallett. He credits this award to name recognition—he’s been cooking in Portsmouth for 11 years—and the tremendous restaurant legacy of the building (two longtime restaurants preceded Black Trumpet here: Blue Strawberry and Lindbergh’s Crossing). “I’m surrounded by equally talented if not more talented young cooks and servers,” Mallett adds. “This food and restaurant represent a fraction of me and everyone else who touches the menu. I hire people who are talented and I take care of them.” 29 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-0887, www.blacktrumpetbistro.com.
Runners-up:
Phelps Dieck, The Green Monkey, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thegreenmonkey.net
Greg Sessler, Cava, Portsmouth, N.H., www.cavatapasandwinebar.com
Simon Lampert, Four Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.fouronstate.com
Chocolatier
Byrne & Carlson
Every ingredient of these extraordinary handmade chocolates has an amazing pedigree, from the cocoa beans to the hazelnut paste to the glacé fruits. But it’s the stunning beauty of many items that make a visit to the store an experience. Check out the hand-embellished artisan chocolate bar decorated in an Art Nouveau botanical motif with candied violets and homegrown organic mint, or the molded chocolate seashells. And the truffles are always terrific. 121 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., and 60 State Road, Kittery, Maine, 888-559-9778, www.byrneandcarlson.com.
Runners-up:
Lindt, Kittery and South Portland, Maine, and Portsmouth and Stratham, N.H., www.lindtusa.com
The Chocolatier, Exeter, N.H., www.the-chocolatier.com
Sanborn’s Fine Candies, Hampton, N.H., www.sanbornscandies.com
 Comfort Food
The Common Man
As a Seacoast newcomer, The Common Man certainly made a splash this year (see “New Restaurant”, page 88). You might go again and again just to try all the chain’s traditional offerings, like baked macaroni and cheese, crab cakes, New England pot roast, walnut-crusted chicken breast with apple cider glaze, white chocolate bread pudding. The Portsmouth location also serves fresh seafood dishes, to honor its new Seacoast home. 96 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-334-6225, www.thecman.com.
Runners-up:
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thefriendlytoast.net
The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.portsmouthbrewery.com
Flatbread Company, Portsmouth, N.H., www.flatbreadcompany.com
Cooking School
Stonewall Kitchen Cooking School
This state-of-the-art facility, housed in the Stonewall Kitchen flagship retail store in York, Maine, caters to casual, enthusiastic cooks looking to improve their confidence and culinary skills. The instruction, by demonstration, is top notch, whether from the entertaining staff or visiting celebrity cooks. Lots of chef interaction, samples to try, and recipes to take home make it a fun and engaging way to learn about cooking. 2 Stonewall Lane, York, Maine, 877-899-8363, www.stonewallkitchen.com.
Runners-up:
Chez Boucher Cooking School, Hampton, N.H., www.chezboucher.com
Attrezzi, Portsmouth, N.H., www.attrezzinh.com
Li Yuen Chinese Culinary Specialties, North Hampton, N.H., 603-964-8181 (no website)
Deck
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina
Fresh salt air, a two-level deck, the sight of tugboats on the Piscataqua River as a backdrop… what could be better than eating nachos and sipping margaritas on Poco’s newly renovated deck? When you spot the lively crowds at the tables or bellied up to the bar, you know it's summer on the Seacoast. 37 Bow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5967, www.pocosbowstreetcantina.com.
Runners-up:
The Old Ferry Landing, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5510 (no website)
River House, Portsmouth, N.H., www.riverhouse53bow.com
Harpoon Willy’s, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-4441 (no website)
Diner
Gilley’s PM Lunch
Seating is limited in this tiny hidden hotspot with its leather stools and wooden counters, but folks come for the food and the atmosphere. The ballgame is always on, the grill is fired up, and regulars debate the Sox and Yankees while ordering their cup of joe and “loaded” dogs (i.e., the “Works” plus ketchup). You know you can always get good burgers, dogs, and fries at Gilley’s, and that’s what makes it a classic. 175 Fleet Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-6343, www.gilleyspmlunch.com.
Runners-up:
Maine Diner, Wells, Maine, www.mainediner.com
Fast Eddie’s Diner, Hampton, N.H., www.fasteddiesdiner.com
Roundabout Diner & Lounge, Portsmouth, N.H., www.roundaboutdiner.com
Farmers’ Market/Farmstand
Portsmouth Farmers’ Market
At the Seacoast’s largest and oldest farmers’ market, operating since 1977, you’ll find fresh produce, handcrafted goods, and homemade foods and beverages—all local, all the time. They sell farmers’ market gift certificates, too! Saturdays, City Hall lot, 1 Junkins Avenue, Portsmouth, N.H., www.seacoastgrowers.org.
Runners-up:
Barker’s Farm, Stratham, N.H., 603-778-1039 (no website)
Golden Harvest Produce Market, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-2113, (no website)
Tuttle’s Red Barn, Dover, N.H., www.tuttlesredbarn.net
 Fine Dining
Ristorante Massimo
Executive Chef Jethro Loichle prepares beautiful, authentic dishes from all regions of Italy. He and his staff select the fresh seafood, meats, fruits, and vegetables. They also cure the meats and make the bread and pasta from scratch. Add to that an impressive wine list, pampering service, and a European-style ambiance, and it’s no wonder Ristorante Massimo continues as an icon of elegance in the minds of locals and visitors. 59 Penhallow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-4000, www.ristorantemassimo.com.
Runners-up:
Black Trumpet, Portsmouth, N.H., www.blacktrumpetbistro.com
Anneke Jans, Kittery, Maine, www.annekejans.net
The Wellington Room, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thewellingtonroom.com
Fish Market
Seaport Fish
Seaport Fish is a processor as well as wholesaler and retailer, so they hand-pick and hand-cut each fish to your specifications. A new focus is prepared, ready-to-go items, such as chowders, bisques, and dips, plus gourmet foods, wine, beer, flowers, and fresh vegetables and fruits. 13 Sagamore Road, Rye, N.H., 603-436-7286, www.seaportfish.com.
Runners-up:
Sander’s Fish Market, Portsmouth, N.H., www.sandersfish.com
Al’s Seafood, North Hampton, N.H., www.taylorlobster.com
Sue’s Seafood, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-5608 (no website)
Fried Seafood
Petey’s Summertime Seafood and Bar
It’s summer year-round at Petey’s, what with the ocean view and an assortment of crispy fried ocean goodies, including fresh (never frozen) melt-in-your-mouth haddock, sea scallops, jumbo and native shrimp, clams, crab cakes, and lobster tail, all fried in vegetable oil. Served with french fries, of course. 1323 Ocean Boulevard, Rye, N.H., 603-433-1937, www.peteys.com.
Runners-up:
Bob’s Clam Hut, Kittery, Maine, www.bobsclamhut.com
Newick’s, Dover, N.H., www.newicks.com
Weathervane, Kittery, Maine, www.weathervaneseafoods.com
Gourmet Food Market
Philbrick’s Fresh Market
Whether you’re looking for fresh produce, local specialty vendors, great meals to go, a bottle of wine, or advice on what to have for dinner, Philbrick’s is one-stop shopping. Known for their variety
of unique, organic, and healthy foods, Philbrick’s has only increased their commitment to sustainable meat, dairy, seafood, and produce, adding six new local farms to their roster of suppliers in the
past year. 775 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-422-6758, www.philbricksfreshmarket.com.
Runners-up:
Fiddlehead Farms Marketplace, Dover, N.H., www.fiddleheadfarmsmarket.com
On the Vine Marketplace, Exeter, N.H., www.onthevinemarketplace.com
The Meat House, Portsmouth, N.H., www.themeathouse.com
Health Food Market
Portsmouth Health Food Center
Owner Scott Nelson runs his own organic farm, which is just one local supply source for the market’s beautiful pesticide-free produce. The staff in the supplement section are knowledgeable and friendly, and the store’s takeout café, Madeline’s Truly Organic Kitchen, offers delicious goodies to go. For more than 33 years, Portsmouth Health Food Center has been at the forefront of the local health food scene. 151 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-1722, www.portsmouthhealthfood.com.
Runners-up:
Blue Moon Market & Café, Exeter, N.H., www.bluemoonmarket.net
Philbrick’s Fresh Market, Portsmouth, N.H., www.philbricksfreshmarket.com
Dover Natural Marketplace & Café, Dover, N.H., 603-749-9999 (no website)
 Ice Cream
Annabelle’s Natural Ice Cream
Annabelle’s is classified as super premium (16-plus percent butterfat), so the quality is noticeably higher than that of the average pint. Some fans pay big bucks to have it shipped out of state. All-natural ice cream means no artificial colors or flavors—the mint ice cream is not green, nor is the pistachio. The creative roster of flavors includes New Hampshire Pure Maple Walnut, Espresso Coffee, and Cashew Caramel Cluster. 49 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3400, www.annabellesicecream.com.
Runners-up:
Lago’s Lone Oak, Rye and Rochester, N.H., www.lagos-lone-oak.com
Izzy’s Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1053 (no website)
The Ice House, Rye, N.H., www.theicehouserestaurant.com
Kid Friendly
Flatbread Company
On any early evening, Flatbread is bustling with families, drawn by a great menu of healthy pizzas and salads, a welcoming atmosphere, and simple, kid-proof decor. Children flock to watch the pizzas being made in the open wood-fired oven. Their drawings decorate the menu covers and are strung on clotheslines running throughout the room. Flatbread’s mission to support natural, organic food and recycling takes kids to heart, too. 138 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-7888, www.flatbreadcompany.com.
Runners-up:
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thefriendlytoast.net
Weathervane, Kittery, Maine, www.weathervaneseafoods.com
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant, Exeter and Portsmouth, N.H., www.margs.com
Kitchen Store
Stonewall Kitchen
One of nine locations for the local specialty food manufacturer, Stonewall Kitchen is filled with hundreds of the company’s award-winning products as well as specialized items for seasonal entertaining and gift giving. Bakeware, spatulas, grilling grids, dishware, napkin holders, serving pieces, teapots—whatever’s unique or different (a Danish ebelskiver pan, anyone?) can be found here. The friendly, knowledgeable staff and beautifully designed space are what you’d expect from this successful, local-grown company. 10 Pleasant Street #102, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-422-7303, www.stonewallkitchen.com.
Runners-up:
LeRoux Kitchen, Portsmouth, N.H., www.lerouxkitchen.com
Attrezzi, Portsmouth, N.H., www.attrezzinh.com
Kitchen & Company, Newington, N.H., www.thekitchenstore.com
Late Night
Gilley’s PM Lunch
Gilley’s is an icon—a Portsmouth fixture for decades. And with only 10 seats, late night (and early a.m.) is a great time to stop in, whether it’s after the theater or a night on the town. Gilley’s tasty old-fashioned burgers and dogs satisfy the stomach, and the welcoming atmosphere nourishes the soul. Open till 2:30 in the morning most days. 175 Fleet Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-6343, www.gilleyspmlunch.com.
Runners-up:
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thefriendlytoast.net
The Portsmouth Brewery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.portsmouthbrewery.com
Brazo, Portsmouth, N.H., www.brazorestaurant.com
Lobster Dinner
Warren’s Lobster House
For 70 years customers from far and wide have flocked to Warren’s to enjoy the king of crustaceans with melted butter, boiled, baked, stuffed, sautéed, and more. The Downeast Shore dinner includes your choice of lobster plus a cup of clam chowder, mussels or clams, fries or onions rings, the huge (60 items) and famous salad bar, and dessert. Plus, Warren’s boasts one of the best river views on the Seacoast. 11 Water Street, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-1630, www.lobsterhouse.com.
Runners-up:
Chauncey Creek Lobster Pier, Kittery Point, Maine, www.chaunceycreek.com
Petey’s Summertime Seafood and Bar, Rye, N.H., www.peteys.com
Robert’s Maine Grill, Kittery, Maine, www.robertsmainegrill.com
Lobster Roll
The Beach Plum
There may be more than 40 teenagers on the payroll, but never fear. Longtime loyal kitchen staff with years of experience put together the most awesome lobster roll around. Heaped with the highest quality lobster meat (only hard shell) and just a touch of mayo, these lobster rolls look like small footballs. The Beach Plum also makes a foot-long version. 17 Ocean Boulevard, Route 1A, North Hampton, N.H., 603-964-7451, www.thebeachplum.net.
Runners-up:
Bob’s Clam Hut, Kittery, Maine, www.bobsclamhut.com
Petey’s Summertime Seafood and Bar, Rye, N.H., www.peteys.com
Robert’s Maine Grill, Kittery, Maine, www.robertsmainegrill.com
 Margarita
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant
True to its name, the Margaritas chain takes this cocktail to new heights, with versions like sour apple, mango, pomegranate, and “Mad Melon.” There’s even the “Heavens to Margatroid,” featuring seven different liqueurs. Most popular at this location? The Original, with Patrón Tequila. Friendly, longtime staffers put guests first. 775 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5828, www.margs.com.
Runners-up:
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., www.pocosbowstreetcantina.com
Agavé Mexican Bistro Dos, Portsmouth, N.H., www.agavemexicanbistrodos.com
Loco Coco’s Tacos, Kittery, Maine, www.locococos.com
Martini
The Green Monkey
A tantalizing blend of vodka, Midori, pineapple juice, and lemon make up The Green Monkey's namesake martini, but the rest of the drinks list holds many other temptations (Espresso Hazelnut Martini, Blood Orange Martini…). The owners and bar staff collaborate on the concoctions, and terrific happy hour specials make it fun and easy to give them your feedback. 86 Pleasant Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-427-1010, www.thegreenmonkey.net.
New Restaurant
The Common Man
While new to the Seacoast, The Common Man has roots inland 40 years deep. High-quality yet affordable American food is the hallmark of this family of unpretentious restaurants, along with comfortable settings, distinctive architectural details, and welcoming service. Owner Alex Ray and partner Diane Downing seem positively addicted to creating inviting spaces and good memories around great-value food and drink. One taste of the delicious maple-glazed pork tenderloin will leave you convinced of it. 96 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-334-6225, www.thecman.com.
Runners-up:
River House, Portsmouth, N.H., www.riverhouse53bow.com
Rí Rá, Portsmouth, N.H., www.rira.com
Seaglass, Salisbury, Mass., www.seaglassoceanside.com
Pizza
Flatbread Company
Organic produce, free-range chicken, and homemade, nitrate-free pepperoni and sausage top Flatbread’s pizzas. Spring water, organic flour, kosher salt, and real cake yeast form the dough. All this goes into a wood-fired oven that was hand-built with a stone base and dome made of clay, hay, ash, and sand. And this local favorite has a conscience, too—Flatbread is committed to giving back to the communities it serves. 138 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-7888, www.flatbreadcompany.com.
Runners-up:
La Festa Brick & Brew, Dover, N.H., www.lafestabrickandbrew.com
Portsmouth Gaslight Company, Portsmouth, N.H., www.portsmouthgaslight.com
Joe’s New York Pizza, Portsmouth, N.H., www.joesnypizza.com
 Restaurant
The Green Monkey
Delicious and varied cuisine, creative libations, down-to-earth hospitality, and a friendly, longtime staff have served The Green Monkey well through the years, winning it Best Restaurant accolades yet again. These days the seasonally changing menu shows even more commitment to local, sustainable purveyors, and the dining room is even busier, often with corporate parties. Owners Phelps Dieck and Deb Weeks launched Seacoast Catering this year, transporting their signature recipes for success to all kinds of venues and occasions. 86 Pleasant Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-427-1010, www.thegreenmonkey.net.
Restaurant View
The Wellington Room
From its second-floor perch, The Wellington Room offers a commanding view of the Piscataqua, stretching past two bridges and on up into Great Bay. Watch sailboats and commercial ships thread their way, or see the sky blaze with color as the sun sets. Even at night the effect is magical. And the farm-to-table cuisine is impeccably prepared and beautiful. The small restaurant encourages reservations, but takes a few walk-ins. 67 Bow Street #2, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-2989, www.thewellingtonroom.com.
Runners-up:
Latitudes at Wentworth by the Sea, New Castle, N.H., www.wentworth.com
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., www.pocosbowstreetcantina.com
River House, Portsmouth, N.H., www.riverhouse53bow.com
Romantic Dinner
Ristorante Massimo
Ristorante Massimo wraps you in romance with its warm lighting, quaint brick-and-stone grotto walls, Old World paintings, and tables perfectly set with candles and flowers. Add to that world-class Italian cuisine, fine wine, and attentive staff, and how can romance not bloom? Ask for the intimate booth under the brick archway at the back of the restaurant. 59 Penhallow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-4000, www.ristorantemassimo.com.
Runners-up:
Black Trumpet, Portsmouth, N.H., www.blacktrumpetbistro.com
The Wellington Room, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thewellingtonroom.com
Four, Portsmouth, N.H., www.fouronstate.com
Sandwich
Celebrity Sandwich
Don’t be daunted by the menu, with some 125 sandwich combinations, each named after a different celebrity; they’re all good, combos of meats, veggies, and cheeses layered on tasty breads including home-baked foccacia, herb Parmesan, and crusty French. Plus there’s the “food hotline” (603-433-2277), where you can hear a daily changing recorded message of mouthwatering-sounding specials. It will make you very hungry. 171 Islington Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-433-7009, www.celebritysandwich.com.
Runners-up:
Moe’s Italian Sandwiches, Dover, Exeter, and Portsmouth, N.H., www.moesitaliansandwiches.com
Ceres Bakery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.ceresbakery.com
Me & Ollie’s, Portsmouth, N.H., www.meandollies.com
Seafood
Jumpin’ Jay’s Fish Cafe
Jumpin’ Jay’s is renowned for its Haddock Piccata, but this casually hip restaurant also serves a number of other intriguing fish dishes, plus has a great raw bar (with dozens of styles of oysters), terrific crab cakes, and six to eight “Catch of the Day” specials. Less well known is that all the seafood shells go to the Coastal Conservation Association (CCA) of New Hampshire to rebuild the oyster bed in Great Bay. 50 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-766-3474, www.jumpinjays.com.
Runners-up:
Petey’s Summertime Seafood and Bar, Rye, N.H., www.peteys.com
Robert’s Maine Grill, Kittery, Maine, www.robertsmainegrill.com
Newick’s, Dover, N.H., www.newicks.com
Special Occasion
Ristorante Massimo
Proprietor/host Massimo Morgia warmly welcomes guests as they enter his restaurant to discover the perfect Italian meal in an unforgettable setting. White tablecloths and china, original framed oil paintings on the brick walls, and impeccable service set the tone here. A romantic first date, a wedding anniversary, a business meeting, or a family reunion all receive the same first-class hospitality. And just the right amount of contemporary innovation keeps the menu exciting and intriguing. 59 Penhallow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-4000, www.ristorantemassimo.com.
Runners-up:
Wentworth by the Sea, New Castle, N.H., www.wentworth.com
Black Trumpet, Portsmouth, N.H., www.blacktrumpetbistro.com
White Barn Inn, Kennebunk, Maine, www.whitebarninn.com
Steakhouse
Library Restaurant
From the golden lions marking the entrance to the book-lined walls, Library Restaurant exudes casual elegance. This Library is all about the steaks: New York, Bone-in Ribeye, Porterhouse, Filet. Make your selection, then choose from an extensive list of sauces and sides. The restaurant’s martini bar boasts one of the largest selections of vodka north of Boston. 401 State Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5202, www.libraryrestaurant.com.
Runners-up:
Four, Portsmouth, N.H., www.fouronstate.com
Orchard Street Chop Shop, Dover, N.H.,
www.orchardstreetchopshop.com
Wells Beach Steakhouse, Wells, Maine, www.wellsbeachsteakhouse.com
Sushi
Sake Japanese Restaurant
Conveniently located in the heart of downtown Portsmouth, Sake has been a mainstay on the Seacoast sushi scene since 1996. The freshness and diversity of the fish give Sake its edge, as do the sushi chefs at the bar, who are happy to tell you what’s fresh and good to try each day. 141 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1822, www.portsmouthsake.com.
Runners-up:
Sakurabana, Portsmouth, N.H., www.sakurabananh.com
Shio Japanese Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.shiojapaneserestaurant.com
Taipei & Tokyo, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-3668 (no website)
Vegetarian
Blue Moon Market & Café
Blue Moon Market & Café is dedicated to providing delicious, healthy foods and products. The café offers sandwiches (complete with vegetarian and vegan options), kids’ meals, and a great salad bar. There’s also a case full of healthy dinners to go, with many local farm products as ingredients. Blue Moon is committed to helping people learn more about health and wellness, offering cooking and yoga classes. 8 Clifford Street, Exeter, N.H., 603-778-6850, www.bluemoonmarket.net.
Runners-up:
The Juicery, Portsmouth, N.H., www.portsmouthjuicery.com
Flatbread Company, Portsmouth, N.H., www.flatbreadcompany.com
Susty’s Cafe, Northwood, N.H., 603-942-5862 (no website)
Wine List
Cava Tapas and Wine Bar
Named for a Spanish sparkling wine, Cava offers an eclectic, high-quality wine selection. Every single bottle is available by the glass and half-glass (called a copa), and you can buy a closed bottle
to take home. Matched with the changing menu of Spanish and Mediterranean-inspired tapas dishes, Cava is a paradise for those who enjoy little tastes of a great many delicious things. 10 Commercial Alley, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-319-1575, www.cavatapasandwinebar.com.
Runners-up:
Ristorante Massimo, Portsmouth, N.H., www.ristorantemassimo.com
Black Trumpet, Portsmouth, N.H., www.blacktrumpetbistro.com
Library Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.libraryrestaurant.com
 Wine Shop
Ceres Street Wine Merchants
Proprietor David Campbell says, “I handpick a bunch of wines thought to be of some special interest and leave the mass market to others.” It’s a great mission for this smallish shop, whose dynamic, seasonally changing inventory of wines from around the world offers something for everyone. Be sure to check out the wine merchandise: there’s everything from Riedel stemware to a T-shirt declaring, “Squeeze Me, Crush Me, Make Me Wine.” 65 Ceres Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-2640, www.cereswine.com.
Runners-up:
Dover Wine Company, Dover, N.H., www.doverwine.com
South Street & Vine, Portsmouth, N.H., www.southstreetandvine.com
Corks and Curds, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-5564 (no website)
Winery, local
Flag Hill
This scenic, 20-plus-acre vineyard, winery, and distillery produces grape, fruit, and dessert wines as well as New Hampshire’s first port and the winery’s award-winning cranberry liqueur. It also houses New Hampshire’s first distillery, which produces General John Stark vodka. Flag Hill encourages visitors to stop by its new free tasting room, and holds monthly dinners in its dining room. 297 North River Road, Lee, N.H., 603-659-2949, www.flaghillwinery.com.
Runners-up:
Jewell Towne Vineyards, South Hampton, N.H., www.jewelltownevineyards.com
Zorvino Vineyard, Sandown, N.H., www.zorvino.com
Sweet Baby Vineyard, Kensington, N.H., www.sweetbabyvineyard.com
Wings
Wings Your Way
Spectacular wings paired with your choice of 16 sauces—what could be better? Includes four types of Buffalo, plus Teriyaki, Chili-Lime, Thai Peanut, Mango-Habanero, and several more. The menu encourages you to ask for a taste before choosing, and a sense of humor shines through with offerings like the Al Gore (“with no sauce or spice of any kind”) and The Donald ($8,598 for a gold-plated platter featuring 10,000 wings). 215 Lafayette Road, North Hampton, N.H., 603-964-3333, www.wingsyourway.com.
Runners-up:
Wing-itz, Portsmouth, N.H., home.comcast.net/~wingitz/
Bratskellar, Portsmouth, N.H., www.dinnerhorn.com
Fat Belly’s Grill and Bar, Portsmouth, N.H., www.fatbellysgrillandbar.com
Best Inexpensive Eats
A full day’s worth of good food and great value.
BREAKFAST
The Golden Egg
Debbie Gosselin opened this comfy yet creative breakfast-and-lunch spot in 1983, and she’s got customers that go back that far, too. “Fresh made” is the order of the day, along with reasonable prices and efficient service. Her various styles of Eggs Benedict, flavorful omelets, hearty home fries, and terrific house-made cinnamon rolls and desserts make great fuel for the morning. Go hungry, go often, then go get ’em! 960 Sagamore Avenue, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-0519, www.goldeneggrestaurant.com.
Runners-up
The Friendly Toast, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thefriendlytoast.net
Café Espresso, Portsmouth, N.H., www.cafe--espresso.com
Colby’s Breakfast & Lunch, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3033 (no website)
LUNCH
Café Nostimo
This authentic Greek eatery has a casual, friendly atmosphere. Most of the lunch specials, including the marinated kabobs, run under $8 and include pita, tzatziki, a Greek salad, and your choice of rice pilaf or fries. If you want, just nibble on crispy pan-fried ketethes (Greek meatballs) with a side of Greek-style green beans and sip some avegolemono (creamy egg-lemon soup with chicken and rice)—secret family recipes generations old. Madison Village, 72 Mirona Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3100, www.cafenostimo.com.
Runners-up
Gilley’s PM Lunch, Portsmouth, N.H., www.gilleyspmlunch.com
The Green Bean, Dover, Exeter, and Portsmouth, N.H., www.nhgreenbean.com
Moe’s Italian Sandwiches, Dover, Exeter, and Portsmouth, N.H., www.moesitaliansandwiches.com
DINNER
Café Nostimo
“Nostimo” means “delicious” in Greek, which explains the many loyal patrons of this restaurant. Owners Nancy and Dean Zottos serve made-to-order Greek (and American) favorites at reasonable prices. Eat in, take out, or visit their new adjoining market, where you can pick up ready-to-bake items (including moussaka, spanakopita, and pastichio) for under $10, along with hard-to-find Greek specialty items. Madison Village, 72 Mirona Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3100, www.cafenostimo.com.
Runners-up
Dos Amigos Burritos, Concord, Dover, and Portsmouth, N.H., www.dosamigosburritos.com
Bratskellar, Portsmouth, N.H., www.dinnerhorn.com
The Rusty Hammer, Portsmouth, N.H., www.therustyhammer.com
Best Ethnic Cuisine
CHINESE
Taipei & Tokyo, 1508 Woodbury Avenue, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-3668 (no website)
Runners-up
Kim Lai Chinese Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.kim-lai.com
Ocean Wok, Hampton, N.H., www.oceanwok.com
Greenleaves, York, Maine, www.greenleavesrestaurant.com
GREEK
Cafe Nostimo, Madison Village, 72 Mirona Road, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-3100, www.cafenostimo.com
Runners-up
Ithaki Mediterranean Cuisine, Ipswich, Mass., www.ithakicuisine.com
Pauly’s Pocket, Durham, N.H., 603-868-3110 (no website)
Steve’s Diner, Exeter, N.H., 603-772-5733 (no website)
INDIAN
Shalimar India, 80 Hanover Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-427-2959, www.shalimarindia.com.
Runners-up
Tulsi, Kittery, Maine, www.tulsiindianrestaurant.com
Taste of India, Dover, N.H., www.taste-of-india.org
Mr. India Restaurant, Newburyport, Mass., www.misterindiarestaurant.com
IRISH PUB
Rí Rá, 22-26 Market Square, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-319-1680, www.rira.com
Runners-up
The Holy Grail, Epping, N.H., www.theholygrailpub.com
Kelley’s Row, Dover, N.H., www.kelleysrow.com
The Peddler’s Daughter, Haverhill, Mass., www.thepeddlersdaughter.com
ITALIAN
Ristorante Massimo, 59 Penhallow Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-436-4000, www.ristorantemassimo.com
Runners-up
Café Mediterráneo, Portsmouth, N.H.,
www.cafe-mediterraneo.com
Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., www.radicirestaurant.com
The Rosa Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.therosa.com
JAPANESE
Sake Japanese Restaurant, 141 Congress Street, Portsmouth, N.H., 603-431-1822, www.portsmouthsake.com
Runners-up
Sakurabana, Portsmouth, N.H., www.sakurabananh.com
Shio Japanese Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.shiojapaneserestaurant.com
Hibachi Japanese Steak House, Portsmouth, N.H., www.hibachinh.com
MEXICAN
Loco Coco’s Tacos, 36 Walker Street, Kittery, Maine, 207-438-9322, www.locococos.com
Runners-up
Agavé Mexican Bistro Dos, Portsmouth, N.H., www.agavemexicanbistrodos.com
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant, Dover, Exeter, and Portsmouth, N.H., www.margs.com
Poco’s Bow Street Cantina, Portsmouth, N.H., www.pocosbowstreetcantina.com
THAI
Tasty Thai, Kittery Center Circle, 182 State Road, Kittery, Maine, 207-439-9988, www.tastythaikittery.com
Runners-up
Thai Paradise, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thaiparadisecusine.com
Thai Cuisine, Dover, N.H., www.thaicuisine.com
Pad Thai Restaurant, Exeter, N.H., www.padthaiexeter.com
Top 20 Restaurants
1. The Green Monkey, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thegreenmonkey.net
2. Jumpin’ Jay’s Fish Cafe, Portsmouth, N.H., www.jumpinjays.com
3. Anneke Jans, Kittery, Maine, www.annekejans.net
4. Black Trumpet, Portsmouth, N.H., www.blacktrumpetbistro.com
5. Cava Tapas and Wine Bar, Portsmouth, N.H., www.cavatapasandwinebar.com
6. Brazo, Portsmouth, N.H., www.brazorestaurant.com
7. Ristorante Massimo, Portsmouth, N.H., www.ristorantemassimo.com
8. Café Mediterráneo, Portsmouth, N.H., www.cafe-mediterraneo.com
9. The Wellington Room, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thewellingtonroom.com
10. Four, Portsmouth, N.H., www.fouronstate.com
11. Zampa, Epping, N.H., www.zampa.com
12. Radici, Portsmouth, N.H., www.radicirestaurant.com
13. Robert’s Maine Grill, Kittery, Maine, www.robertsmainegrill.com
14. Blue Mermaid Island Grill, Portsmouth, N.H., www.bluemermaid.com
15. Library Restaurant, Portsmouth, N.H., www.libraryrestaurant.com
16. Pesce Italian Kitchen & Bar, Portsmouth, N.H., www.pesceblue.com
17. River House, Portsmouth, N.H., www.riverhouse53bow.com
18. The Common Man, Portsmouth, N.H., www.thecman.com
19. Blue Sky, York Beach, Maine, www.blueskyonyorkbeach.com
20. Orchard Street Chop Shop, Dover, N.H., www.orchardstreetchopshop.com
|
The Wellington Room
T
